Abstracting and Indexing

  • Google Scholar
  • CrossRef
  • WorldCat
  • ResearchGate
  • Academic Keys
  • DRJI
  • Microsoft Academic
  • Academia.edu
  • OpenAIRE

A Study of Doppler Velocimetry in Pre-eclampsia Patients, and their Perinatal Outcome

Article Information

Rahul Khatri*, Bhoomika Jain, Sabrina Mhapankar, Sushil Kumar

MGM Medical College and research Center, Navi Mumbai, India

*Corresponding Author: Rahul Khatri, MGM Medical College and research Center, Navi Mumbai, India

Received: 16 March 2021; Accepted: 24 March 2021; Published: 16 April 2021

Citation: Rahul Khatri, Bhoomika Jain, Sabrina Mhapankar, Sushil Kumar. A Study of Doppler Velocimetry in Pre-eclampsia Patients, and their Perinatal Outcome. Obstetrics and Gynecology Research 4 (2021): 090-100.

View / Download Pdf Share at Facebook

Abstract

Pre-eclampsia and IUGR are important causes of maternal and perinatal morbidity and mortality. Pre-eclampsia is a multisystem disorder, in normal pregnancies trophoblastic invasion transforms high resistance spiral arteries into low impedance uteroplacental circulation. This uteroplacental circulation remains incomplete in Pre-eclampsia and IUGR. This study is to Correlate The Doppler Findings With The Fetal Outcome in Pre-eclampsia patiens, and helps decide appropriate time for delivery with least perinatal morbidity.

Keywords

Pre-eclampsia, IUGR, Doppler Changes, Neonatal Complications

Pre-eclampsia articles; IUGR articles; Doppler Changes articles; Neonatal Complications articles

Article Details

1. Introduction

Pre-eclampsia and IUGR are important causes of maternal and perinatal morbidity and mortality. In normal pregnancies trophoblastic invasion transforms high resistance spiral arteries into low impedance uteroplacental circulation. This uteroplacental circulation remains incomplete in Pre-eclampsia and IUGR [1].

1.1 Pre-eclampsia[1]

Pre-eclampsia is a multisystem disorder of unknown aetiology characterised by development of hypertension to the extent of 140/90 mm hg or more with proteinuria after 20th week in previously normotensive and non proteinuric patient.

1.2 Abnormal development of uteroplacental circulation in the presence of pre-eclampsia [1, 2]

A lack of endovascular infiltration by trophoblast into the myometrial portion of the placental bed spiral arteries is a consistent finding in the presence of preeclampsia. Classically it is held that second wave of endovascular trophoblastic invasion that proceeds in myometrial segments of the spiral arteries from 15 weeks, does not occur in patients who will develop preeclampsia. Lack of physiological conversion is not only apparent in the myometrial segments of spiral arteries, but also in the decidual parts of some of the vessels, so that a proportion of spiral arteries completely fail to undergo throphoblastic invasion and physiological changes. Since unconverted vessels retain ‘high resistance/low capacitance’ properties, the effect on the maternal blood supply to the placenta may be dramatically low. These may manifest as impaired growth of the baby or high bp with proteinuria i.e preeclampsia with its complications. The persistence of high resistance to flow after 24-26wks of gestation provide the rationale to investigate the placental circulation by Doppler and to predict development of Preeclampsia and fetal growth restriction.

1.3 Doppler velocimetry [2]

The use of Doppler ultrasound for the evaluation of the fetal circulation is based on the physical principle of change in the frequency of sound wave when it is reflected by a moving object. This principle was described in 1842 by the Austrian physicist and mathematician Johann Christian Doppler. Doppler observed that the frequency of the sound waves reflected by a static object was identical to that before being reflected. In contrast, the frequency of the sound waves reflected form a moving object, such as blood inside a blood vessel, was different from the original frequency and proportional to the velocity of the moving object (Doppler effect). Therefore, blood velocity and resistance to flow can be evaluated using Doppler effect. During Doppler fetal and maternal vessels are interrogated with ultrasound waves. Doppler study is a non-invasive method for evaluation of pathological hemodynamic changes not only in uteroplacental circulation but also in subsequently altered fetoplacental and fetal circulation. fetoplacental and fetal circulation.

Doppler velocimetry indices include

  1. >Pulsatility index (PI)
  2. >resistance index (RI)
  3. >Sytolic/dystolic velocity ratio (S/D ratio)

In this study we are going to use

  1. Uterine artery Doppler to study uteroplacental circulation
  2. Umbilical artery Doppler to study fetoplacental circulation
  3. Middle cerebral artery Doppler to study fetal circulation

1.4 Doppler changes [2]

Doppler changes in uteroplacental circulation represented by uterine artery

  1. Reduced uterine artery PI
  2. Diastolic notch

Doppler changes in fetoplacental circulation represented by umbilical artery

  1. Reverse diastolic flow
  2. Absent diastolic flow

Doppler changes in fetal circulation is represented by middle cerebral artery

  1. Higher diastolic flow in MCA = increased MCA PI= brain sparing effect

1.5 Aims and objectives

To Correlate The Doppler Findings With The Fetal Outcome

2. Methodology

It is a prospective study of (N >= 100) satisfying the inclusion and exclusion criteria,

  1. Informed Consent will be taken from the relatives or the guardians and patient satisfying the inclusion criteria.
  2. Doppler study will be done on the patients satisfying the inclusion criteria
  3. Demographic details will be recorded along

with the history and clinical examination in the form of a case record form.

  1. Data will be statistically analyzed at the end of data collection.

Inclusion Criteria Patients with preeclampsia characterized by

  1. All the preeclamptic patients with or without complication
  2. > /= 1+ dipstick
  3. After 30 weeks of gestational age
  4. Consenting patients

Exclusion Criteria

  1. patients with unreliable Last menstrual period details and not confirmed by first trimester scans
  2. non consenting patients

3. Results

Cases in the study group: 100. Almost 90% of the patients in the study group fall in the age group of 18-30 years as a majority of deliveries occur in this age group in our set-up. Majority of the patients in the study group were primigravidae. Pre-eclampsia is known to be more common in primigravidae [9]. Out of the total 100 patients 78 were in 37-40 weeks period of gestation. 21 were between 28-36 weeks period of gestation. 2 patients in the study group gave a history of eclampsia in the past pregnancy. 6 patients underwent emergency cacsarean section in the past pregnancy. Majority of the patients admitted (67%) had a diastolic BP of > 100 mm Hg on admission. 66 patients had normal Doppler velocimetry studies in the current series. 34 patients showed abnormal flow velocity waveform of which umbilical artery Doppler formed a majority of cases. 2 patients showed involvement of all 3 vessels on Doppler of the total patients, 10 of them had absent end diastolic flow of these 10 patients, 8 underwent ceasarean section and 2 underwent vaginal trial. There 5 neonatal deaths. The overall prognosis was found to be worst in the subgroup with absent end diastolic flow. 10 patients showed diastolic notching. 2 underwent vaginal trial and 8 patients were taken up for caesarean section. There were 2 neonatal deaths. One patient showed reduced PI and was given a vaginal trial.

Multiple vessel involvement was associated with adverse fetal outcome as is noted in the above table. 2 patients had abnormal uterine + umbilical artery velocimetry, there were neonatal deaths after a stormy perinatal outcome in both cases who underwent emergency caesarean section in this group. There were 6 patients who had abnormal umbilical + middle cerebral artery velocimetry. All 6 cases underwent caesarean section in the subgroup with. Out of 6, 5 had late neonatal deaths. Multiple vessel involvement was associated with very poor prognosis. The average decision to delivery interval in the current study was 24hrs. The decisions were largely influenced by stabilization of maternal hypertension, avoiding respiratory distress syndrome in some neonates by administering 2 doses of corticosteroids 12 hours apart. Patients were closely involved in the decision making process. In patients with absent or reversed umbilical end diastolic flow velocity, the average decision to delivery interval was 8 hours in a majority of patients. 53 patients out of 100 underwent caesarean section in the study group. 18 underwent caesarean section for abnormal fetal heart rate patterns out of which 7 were associated with meconium stained liquor. 10 underwent caesarean section for abnormal Doppler parameters. The patients with abnormal Doppler parameters were delivered preterm and had to get admitted in the nicu for >48hrs due to low birth weight. But those patients who inspite of being pre eclamptic but having a normal Doppler study had a avg baby wt between 2-3 kg. 11 babies with abnormal umbilical artery Doppler had nicu stay more than 48 hrs and also other neonatal complications. The second in the row was involvement of umbilical and MCA Doppler waveforms with maximum neonatal complications.

Age (in Years)

No. of Cases

Percent

18-25

58

58%

26-30

32

32%

31-35

9

9%

> 35

1

1%

Total

100

100%

Table 1: Age Distribution.

Gravidity

No. of Cases

Percent

Primi

56

56%

Multigravida

44

44%

Total

100

100%

Table 2: Gravidity.

Period of Gestation (Weeks)

No. of Cases

Percent

28-36

21

21%

37-40

78

78%

> 40

1

1%

Total

100

100%

Table 3: Period of Gestation.

Associated conditions in the mother

No. of Cases

Percent

PREV LSCS

1

6.7%

PREV LSCS WITH GDM

1

6.7%

H/O ECLAMPSIA

2

13.3%

PREV 2 LSCS

1

6.7%

PREV LSCS

6

40.0%

RPL

2

13.3%

TORCH +

1

6.7%

TWIN GESTATN

1

6.7%

 Total

15

100.0%

Table 4: Associated conditions in the mother.

Preeclampsia

No. of Cases

Percent

Mild

33

33%

Severe

67

67%

Total

100

100%

Table 5: Preeclampsia.

Vessels involved

No. of Cases

Percent

Umbilical artery

15

15%

Umbilical + Uterine Artery

2

2%

Umbilical Artery + Middle Cerebral Artery

6

6%

Uterine Artery

11

11%

Middle Cerebral Artery

8

8%

All three vessels

2

2%

Table 6: Vessels involved as per abnormal Doppler Studies.

Parameters Altered

No. of Cases

Mode of Delivery

Vaginal

LSCS

Live Birth

Still Birth

NND

Live Birth

Still Birth

NND

Increased resistance

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

Absent EDF

10

2

-

-

8

-

5

Reversed EDF

1

-

-

-

1

-

-

Table 7: Umbilical Doppler Velocimetry and Perinatal Outcome.

Parameters altered

No. of Cases

Mode of Delivery

Vaginal

LSCS

Live Birth

Still Birth

NND

Live Birth

Still Birth

NND

Diastolic notching

10

2

-

-

8

-

2

Reduced PI

1

1

-

-

-

-

-

Table 8: Uterine Artery Doppler.

Parameters Altered

No. of Cases

Mode of Deliver

Vaginal

LSCS

Live Birth

Still Birth

NND

Live Birth

Still Birth

NND

Uterine artery+ umbilical artery

2

-

-

-

2

-

2

Umbilical artery + middle cerebral artery

6

-

-

-

6

-

5

Middle cerebral

8

-

-

-

8

-

5

Three vessel involvement

2

-

-

-

2

-

2

Table 9: Velocimetry study involving alternation of two vessels and subsequent outcome.

Duration

No. of Cases

Percent

< 4 hrs

1

1%

4-8 hrs

79

79%

9-12 hrs

17

17%

>12 hrs

3

3%

Total

100

100%

Table 10: Duration between Last Doppler Ultrasound and Delivery.

Indication

No. of Cases

Percent

PREV LSCS

10

18.9%

FD

11

20.8%

UNCONTROLLED HTN

1

1.9%

MSAF+FD

7

13.2%

FOI

2

3.8%

DOPPLER CHANGES(DC)

10

18.9%

NPOL

3

5.7%

TWIN GESTATION

1

1.9%

OLIGO

2

3.8%

CPD

4

7.5%

PREV 2 LSCS

2

3.8%

Total

53

100.0%

Table 11: Indication Associated with LSCS.

Baby Weight

No. of Cases

Percentage

<1

2

2%

1-1.5

3

3%

1.6-2

18

18%

2.1-2.5

22

22%

2.6-3

33

33%

3.1-3.5

15

15%

>3.5

7

7%

Total

100

100%

Table 12: Average Baby Weight (in kg ).

Neonatal complications

Umbilical Artery

Uterine Artery

Umbilical+Uterine artery

Umbilical+MCA

Birth Asphyxia

-

-

-

-

Sepsis

1

-

-

1

Jaundice

9

2

2

5

Congenital anomaly

-

-

-

-

IUGR

7

3

2

4

Ventilatory Support

6

2

2

4

Any other

1

1

-

1

Neonatal death

5

2

2

5

NICU> 48 hrs

11

4

2

6

Table 13: Neonatal Complications.

4. Discussion

 Preeclampsia and eclampsia have been recognised as a potentially fatal complication of pregnancy challenging obstetricians for more than a century. It complicates 3-10% of pregnancies and is responsible for a large proportion of maternal and perinatal morbidity and mortality [1]. It is well known that despite extensive research into the etiopathogenesis of this condition expediting delivery of the fetus and placenta have still remained the only effective treatment. The exact timing of delivery remains an issue of debate to most obstetricians. The present prospective observational study includes 100 cases of preeclampsia admitted in a tertiary referral centre. Majority of the delivered patients in the institute have limited resources. Antenatal patients detected to have hypertension were hospitalized and a serial monitoring of the blood pressure was maintained. The baseline hematological investigations performed include a complete hemogram, coagulation profile, liver and renal function tests and urine analysis. A fundoscopic examination is performed by the ophthalmologist to visualize the grades of hypertensive changes. Short acting or long-acting anti hypertensives are administered in the minimum dosage required and stepped up depending on the BP reading. A baseline obstetric scan is performed for every patient to note the composite gestational age. Maternal surveillance includes BP charting and monitoring of symptoms like headache, epigastric distress, blurring of vision, swelling of the body and altered urine output. Fetal surveillance included a daily fetal movement count and a daily cardiotocograph. A Doppler ultrasound is performed whenever there is a high degree of clinical suspicion of fetal growth lag. The decision to perform a Doppler velocimetry is very individualized and based on the clinical judgement of a senior consultant obstetrician.

4.1 Demographic perspectives

In the present study, analysis of demographic data showed that a majority of the patients with preeclampsia were in the age group of 18-25 years. 33% of the patients were in the age group of 25-30 years. Majority of the patients (56%) were primigravidae. Amongst the study group of 100 patients, 67 had severe preeclampsia. As mentioned previously, all these patients had been admitted as identified high risk cases and appropriate treatment was initiated depending on the severity of preeclampsia.

4.2 Umbilical artery doppler

In the present study, abnormal umbilical artery flow velocity waveforms were exclusively seen in 11 patients. Amongst the 11 patients with abnormal umbilical artery Doppler, 10 patients had absent diastolic flow in the umbilical artery and 1 patients had reversed diastolic flow in the umbilical artery. 9 out of 10 patients in this group were delivered by LSCS. There were 5 neonatal deaths. All the 11 babies were admitted for more than 48 hours in the NICU. The main complications seen in the babies in this group were jaundice, convulsions, IUGR and 6 babies required ventilatory support. Though the present study group is small the observations reflect a good specificity of umbilical velocimetry in relation to perinatal morbidity.

A strong relationship between the umbilical artery doppler indices and fetal well-being has been demonstrated in several other studies. Elevation of umbilical artery doppler indices in the presence of positive end diastolic flow is associated with hypoxemia at a steady state [3]. Absent end diastolic flow in the umbilical artery is associated with a significant worsening of hypoxemia and acidemia may be present [4] Yoon and Lee in 1994 [5] in the American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology [5], demonstrated that poor perinatal outcome occurred more frequently in women with an abnormal umbilical artery waveform than those with a normal waveform. Indeed, the rates of preterm delivery, caesarean section for fetal distress, admission to the intensive care, occurrence of significant neonatal morbidity and perinatal death were significantly higher in the patients with an abnormal waveform. Ducey et al [6] reported that 65% of patients of preeclampsia had an abnormal umbilical artery waveform. They suggested that the severity of the disease correlates with the degree of placental ischemia occurring in patients with preeclampsia and that patients with abnormal Doppler velocirnetry have poorer outcomes.

Therefore, a summative inference is that umbilical artery doppler should be offered as a primary and single best line of assessment of the fetoplacental circulation in high-risk pregnant women with preeclampsia and suspected fetal growth restriction. There is good evidence from the Cochrane Pregnancy and Childbirth database based on the outcomes of randomized trials to suggest the use of umbilical artery Doppler for a beneficial effect on perinatal outcome [7]. At an early gestational age reduced or absent umbilical artery end diastolic flow is an indication for increased fetal surveillance, but not necessarily for immediate delivery. However closer to term, severe placental insufficiency reflected by absent umbilical artery end diastolic flow velocity is an indication for delivery. Fetuses with absent umbilical end diastolic flow are more severely growth restricted and are at a higher risk of perinatal morbidity and mortality. They require delivery at an earlier gestational age than those with reverse end diastolic flow.

4.3 Uterine artery doppler

In the present study, diastolic notching was seen in 10 patients. 2 patients had an abnormal umbilical artery flow velocity waveform along with uterine artery notching and 2 patients had an elevated pulsatility index in the middle cerebral artery. 8 patients in this category delivered by caesarean section. The delivered neonates had significantly lower birth weight percentiles. 2 babies developed jaundice, 3 were IUGR and 4 babies spent> 48 hrs in the intensive care unit. 2 babies required ventilatory support. In hypertensive gravidas with a notch in the uterine artery flow velocity waveforms, the impedance to flow in the uterine vascular bed is significantly higher than it is in hypertensive patients without a notch. This suggests that the appearance of a notch reflects a higher impedance to blood flow and the momentary tendency of the uterine artery to close in late systole or early diastole. In the present study, an adverse pregnancy outcome was observed in all patients with diastolic notching regardless of the flow velocity waveforms in the umbilical artery. Additionally, when this pattern in the uterine artery was associated with an increased impedance to flow in the umbilical artery, the incidence of fetal growth restriction increased.

In a large study of 140 hypertensive pregnant patients, Israel Thaler et al [8] reported the additional correlation of the presence or absence of a systolic or diastolic notch alongwith the resistance indices in the uterine arteries on both sides of the uterus. They found that those patients with notches had a significantly higher rate of fetal growth restriction and caesarean delivery (64% vs 12.9%) because of fetal distress (56% vs 29.7%)Vergani P et al [9] also found that the presence of abnormal doppler waveforms at the uterine arteries is associated with a 4 fold increase of adverse neonatal outcome. Park et al in the American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology have shown in their study of 2361 pre eclamptic patients after 28 weeks of gestation, the group with notches had significant differences in the incidence of IUGR (44.7% vs 8.9%) and fetal distress (34.2% vs 3%). Therefore, the inference is that abnormal uterine artery spectra could be carefully taken into consideration during the decision-making process in individualized situations. Currently there is still a lack of robust evidence by controlled randomized trials to suggest the regular use of uterine artery Doppler measurements and their potential role in predicting pregnancy complications associated with abnormal uteroplacental perfusion.

4.4 Middle cerebral artery

In the present study, the pulsatility index of the middle cerebral artery was increased in 8 patients with severe IUGR. Of these 6 patients had a simultaneous increased resistance pattern in the umbilical artery flow velocity waveforms as well. There were 5 neonatal deaths in this group. Middle cerebral artery changes are associated with SGA fetuses. Vyas and Nicolaides et al showed that the pulsatility index of the middle cerebral artery was significantly lower and the mean systolic velocity was higher in SGA fetuses than the respective reference ranges for normal fetuses throughout gestation. The redistribution in hypoxemic SGA fetuses may be transitory with worsening of 02 deficit; the pulsatility index tend to rise which may be attributable to the development of brain edema. He reported a 27 % rate of redistribution among SGA fetuses. It is interesting to note that the changes in the middle cerebral artery were also accompanied by changes in the umbilical artery flow velocity waveforms in this study. Umbilical artery flow velocimetry is easy to perform, not only with color flow imaging, which was used in all our patients, but also with inexpensive continuous wave equipment making the test more suitable as a primary screening tool. The correct visualization of the middle cerebral artery is mandatory to avoid false positive results and cannot be obtained accurately with continuous wave equipment. Strigini et al [10] demonstrated that umbilical artery velocimetry indicates that the vascular structure of the placenta may be abnormal, with or without adverse perinatal outcome. Within this subgroup, at risk for chronic hypoxia of placental origin, abnormal cerebral artery velocimetry indicates that hypoxia has occurred thus endangering the fetus. In fact, he reported that when both umbilical and cerebral velocities were abnormal, 60% fetuses were SGA and had a stormy perinatal outcome. Although an increase in the cerebral arterial end diastolic flow velocimetry may reflect chronic fetal hypoxemia there is no evidence that this measurement will provide additional benefit to perinatal outcome beyond the assessment of the umbilical circulation alone.

4.5 Decision to delivery interval

In the present study, the average interval observed between abnormal doppler findings and delivery of the baby was found to be <24hrs (70%). 78 patients had a decision to delivery interval of 4-8 hrs and 17 patients showed a decision to delivery interval of 9-12 hrs. Analysis showed that the decision to delivery interval was largely influenced by 2 factors. The primary concern was the stabilization of maternal hypertension before planning delivery. The second concern was to avoid respiratory distress syndrome in the premature neonate and enhance lung maturity by administering 2 doses of corticosteroids (betamethasone) 12 hrs apart. Weekly Doppler estimation was offered in all patients included in this study. Hence the decision to deliver the patient was largely dominated by a panoramic and holistic assessment of the clinical situation in every case along with the help of the Doppler study. Patients were closely involved in the crucial decision-making process making them aware of the possibility of adverse perinatal outcome. There was a close liaison with the neonatal intensive care unit to ensure the availability of beds for the neonate. Larger studies would be desirable to determine whether the presence of IUGR or oligohydramnios both at admission results in a significantly higher rate of deterioration in fetal condition during expectant management of preeclampsia.

5. Conclusion

Current evidence suggests that the logical approach to manage suspected uteroplacental insufficiency is a weekly estimation of umbilical artery Doppler. Serial doppler velocimetry and fetal heart rate analysis definitely resulted in more live births.

References

  1. Cunningham FG, Lenevo KJ, Bloom SL, et al. Williams Obstetrics, 23rd edition (2009).
  2. Arias F, Daftary SN, Bhide AG, et al. Practical guide to High-Risk pregnancy and delivery:3rd edition (2008).
  3. Caterina M Bilardo, Kypros H Nicolaides, Stuart Campbell. Doppler measurements of fetal and uteroplacental circulations: Relationship with umbilical venous blood gases measured at cordocentesis, American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology 162 (1990): 115-120.
  4. Nicolaides K, Bilardo Caterina, Soothill P, et al. Absence of end diastolic frequencies in umbilical artery: A sign of fetal hypoxia and acidosis. BMJ (Clinical research ed.) 297 (1988): 1026-1027.
  5. Bo Hyun Yoon, Chul Min Lee, Syng Wook Kim. An abnormal umbilical artery waveform: A strong and independent predictor of adverse perinatal outcome in patients with preeclampsia, American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology 171 (1994): 713-721.
  6. James Ducey, Harold Schulman, George Farmakides, et al. A classification of hypertension in pregnancy based on h Doppler velocimet, American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology 157 (1987): 680-685.
  7. National High School Pressure Education Program: Working group Report On High School Pressure in Pregnancy. Am J Obstet Gynacol 183 (2000): 51.
  8. Thaler I, Weiner Z, Itskovitz J. Systolic or Diastolic notch in umbilical artery blood Flow Velocity Waveforms in hypertensive pregnant patients relationship to outcome Obstet Gynecol 80 (1992): 277-282.
  9. Vergani P, Rondagia N, Andreotti C, et al. Prognostic value of uterine artery Doppler velocimetry in growth restricted fetuses delivered near term. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1987 (2002): 932-936.
  10. Francesca AL Strigini, Giuseppa De Luca, Giovanni Lencioni, et al. Middle Cerebral Artery Velocimetry: Different Clinical Relevance Depending on Umbilical Velocimetry. Obstetrics & Gynecology 90 (1997): 953-957.

© 2016-2021, Copyrights Fortune Journals. All Rights Reserved!